Two horror plush, two very different jobs
The Kidrobot catalog lists both of these as horror-adjacent plush, but they are not interchangeable. The Stephen King's IT Pennywise Horror Phunny Plush is an 8-inch plush from the PHUNNY line, described as a sinisterly squeezable collectible. The Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Sally 24" Premium Plush Doll is a 24-inch display doll that comes in a decorative gift box and has a removable arm and leg that velcro back in place. One is a small, huggable creep; the other is a large, presentation-ready doll. Your decision should start with scale and use, not with which character you like more.
What the catalog confirms about each plush
- Stephen King's IT Pennywise Horror Phunny Plush by Kidrobot: Part of the PHUNNY plush collection, a line of sinisterly squeezable 8-inch plush. The 8-inch size makes Pennywise easy to shelf, stack, or keep on a desk without dominating the space.

Stephen King's IT Pennywise Horror Phunny Plush by Kidrobot - Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Sally 24" Premium Plush Doll in Gift Box: Measures 24 inches tall and comes in a decorative gift box. Sally is a large display piece, and the gift box supports presentation or gifting rather than everyday handling.

Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Sally 24" Premium Plush Doll in Gift Box - Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Sally 24" Premium Plush Doll in Gift Box: Features a removable arm and leg that easily velcro back in place. This is a display or play feature specific to Sally; it is not listed for the Pennywise plush.
- Stephen King's IT Pennywise Horror Phunny Plush by Kidrobot: Described as an IT Pennywise plush toy based on the classic Stephen King film. The character reference is the main draw if you want a recognizable horror icon in a small plush format.
Scale, packaging, and handling compared
The most useful comparison is not character preference but how each plush fits into a room and a routine. Pennywise is small and squeezable; Sally is tall, boxed, and built with removable parts. That changes where each one can go and how much care it needs.
- Size and presence: Pennywise is 8 inches, so it reads as a collectible plush among books or figures. Sally is 24 inches, so she reads as a statement doll that needs visible space.
- Packaging: Sally arrives in a decorative gift box, which makes her easier to give as a present or store between displays. The supplied Pennywise record does not mention a gift box.
- Handling features: Sally's removable arm and leg velcro back in place, a feature the catalog does not list for Pennywise. If you want a plush that can be posed or gently played with, Sally has the more documented interactive detail.
- Shipping restriction: The Sally record states it is available for US, Puerto Rico, and Guam orders only. The Pennywise record does not list that restriction. Check your delivery address before choosing Sally.
Which one fits your shelf or your hug
If you want a small horror plush that can sit on a shelf beside other PHUNNY pieces, the Kidrobot Pennywise plush is the more natural fit. Its 8-inch scale is designed for collecting and squeezing, and the catalog positions it within a larger PHUNNY line of creeps and monsters. It is also the lower-commitment choice if you are new to horror plush.
If you want a large, giftable display doll with a recognizable Nightmare Before Christmas look, the 24-inch Sally premium plush is the stronger choice. The decorative gift box, yarn hair, embroidery, and removable limbs make her a presentation piece rather than a throw-around toy. Just confirm the US, Puerto Rico, and Guam shipping limit before you order.
What the supplied records do not confirm
Neither record supplies care instructions, fabric composition, or age recommendations. Do not assume machine washing, surface cleaning, or child safety from the product descriptions alone. If those details matter to you, treat them as open questions rather than features.
- Care and cleaning: No washing or cleaning method is listed for either plush in the supplied evidence.
- Materials: The records mention yarn hair and embroidery for Sally, but do not give a full material breakdown for either item.
- Age suitability: No age rating or safety certification is supplied for either plush.



